Scenario 1
The call: A piano has been acquired. Free. Not a good sign. An old baby grand without a brand name. Not tuned in many years. But the bills must be paid.
The visit: Someone is there to let me in. Brief introductions. Apologies for various matters—of no real importance. I’m anxious to see the piano. Perhaps, just once, it’s not as bad as I assume and expect.
The view: Sigh. Not pretty. Tan, not ebony. Scratched. Nice stool though, recovered carefully. Sheet music has been moved to an electronic keyboard. Not a bad sign.
The beginning: Top to bottom, each key must be touched and assessed. They’re always low, of course—a quarter or even half-tone. That’s just physics. The red felt to dampen the keys not being tuned. The hammer, which is really a lever. I wonder why it’s called that? And my ears—they say “ear” as in “Do you have the ear for this job?” but really both are needed. These days, some of the young ones are using an app. I don’t understand why. A tuning fork at 440hz is required. After that? Nothing.
The method: Begin in the bass. Play the note and compare to its correct pitch as gauged from the 440. Twist to the left, turn, up, up, until it’s right. A perfect match. Then on up the scale, again and again, to the top register. Those notes of the 88 are always a bit thin, just to say.
The proof: A few scales to make sure, then the playing. I favor Chopin. With eyes closed, ears relaxed, I am for a few minutes a performer. No need for an audience other than myself. And the cosmos.
Scenario 2
Setting: The Palau de la Musica, Barcelona’s premiere recital hall. A Wednesday evening in November.
Program: Alba Ventura plays Chopin, and more. She begins with a set of variations on Prelude #7, in A Major by Mompou. Using the music, at least its presence, she turns pages on the iPad with her left foot. Then Scriabin Deux poems (Skriabin in Spain).
Intermission: The piano—a Steinway—is more beautiful than many. The ornate carvings of the stage reflect just lightly on its raised lid. My work begins. How many notes does it take to change a pitch? How much power from a pianist’s hands? Subtleties beyond my poor reckoning. But the artist said, “D2 is a bit off. Will you please fix?” So of course, it’s done. She’d missed the shade of flatness in A6. No need to tell her. I and two in the audience will notice its new perfection.
Done: Yet I cannot play. Not here. My “place” is the wings from which I watch and listen. What will the artist ask? I cannot question. Perhaps I could and never have. Time is so important. Those few minutes while the audience breaks silence, goes to drink, returns. The tuning yields the desired result. And I am indispensable, or so I shall tell myself as I stop for a scoop—or two—of gelato across the street. She will play the 24 preludes without me, or the sheet music. They are under her fingers and flow from her heart. My work is done.
[I have for years listened as a piano tuner brings the instrument back. This video shows a complete tuning, about an hour. The resolutions I find very satisfying. Below are links to increase general knowledge or add specificity to the scenarios above.]
These are basic tools.
Here is our pianist, Alba Ventura, playing the Federico Mompou Variations on a Theme by Chopin in July 2024.
This is the Chopin prelude he used.
The composer did not perform in public, but here is a recording of him playing this piece in the mid-1950s, with the sheet music to view.
Scriabin’s Deux poemes, with music
Chopin’s 24 Preludes with music, Arthur Rubenstein, considered a benchmark interpreter
