Last October I wrote about incidents in California that led me to recommend civility. After two more weeks there, I have one final suggestion: grace.
Here is the trip, north to south. Sacramento is lovely. The Capitol building, modeled on the one in Washington, D.C., has interior chambers that look virtually identical to the ones in Austin. The family had gone to San Francisco the Saturday before to see the movie of the moment, Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey, at the AMC Metreon, one of the largest true IMAX theaters in the country. My grandson was online the minute tickets became available. But we went to Sacramento for a smaller IMAX. The film may get its own blog. Yes, California has the largest homeless population in the country. Yes, I’ve heard about the street filth. We just didn’t see it.
Next, I saw Macbeth in a modern verse “translation” at Shakespeare by the Sea. So, English to English? If you say translation, maybe people will think it was Old English in the original? I don’t know, but the audience was widely diverse in all demographics, and appreciative. The five ambulances heard throughout the performance may have added context. The famous passages were unchanged, so the “translator” wasn’t crazy.
I don’t like musicals, but I finally agreed to see Hadestown and was surprised, amazed even, at the performances and the depth of the story. Anaïs Mitchell weaves together the myths of Orpheus, Eurydice, Hades, and Persephone into something closer to opera than Broadway. Hades and Persephone rule Hades (though she drinks heavily at her speakeasy). Orpheus falls in love with Eurydice, who goes willingly into Hades for food security. Hermes narrates. There aren’t many tunes to hum, but something transforms the familiar into something more personal.
People watching, the greatest fun. In Los Angeles, they are observably better looking than the ones in northern California. The ones in Marysville, for example, looked like those in any small Texas town. Southern California—wealthier, busier, more scenic—attracts beautiful people. In the upscale store Erewhon, I was startled to see a stunning young woman, long blond hair, tanned, in a fashionable linen blouse and slacks with her eight and three-quarter months pregnant belly on display. Uncovered, on display. It was, well, beautiful, but I doubt they do that in Marysville. This video satirizes the store, in fact the one I visited. Actually, I didn’t think some of the prices or products were unreasonable. Maybe next time.
Our last outing was to the Hollywood Bowl for Gershwin’s Rhapsody in Blue and Shostakovich’s Fifth Symphony. Conrad Tao was the pianist, and he was…energetic. This video is that performance, though probably illegal. Here he is in Venice.
The Shostakovich is performed frequently, but open to interpretation. Written in response to Party criticism, it marks a shift in the composer’s approach, at least superficially. The audience reaction was ecstatic—which was itself problematic for Soviet authorities. Is everything political? That unsourced quotation—“All human relationships are based on a struggle for power”— comes to mind.
But let’s just consider a tiny element: tempo. Marin Alsop took the final movement at an astonishingly slow tempo compared with Leonard Bernstein’s famous recording. The difference completely changes the emotional effect. Here she is with the Swedish Radio Symphony. Go to 37:48. It’s the last 13 minutes of the piece. Here is Leonard Bernstein and the New York Philharmonic. His version is just under 9 minutes. Calm versus breakneck.
It was at the Bowl that my theme for California developed for this last version. Just as I was remarking that we would be standing to sing the national anthem if in Dallas, that was exactly what we were invited to do. I’m sure out of thousands, not everyone did, and not everyone had their hands over their hearts. But it was moving—and surprising.
But that’s not all. Some distance over on a hill to the right was a large, lighted cross. Again, I was surprised. Someone in this town had put it up, kept it up, and paid for lighting. Impressive.
So, give them some grace. Patience or mercy, even pity if you must. They have real struggles. Gas is almost $8.00 up near Lake Tahoe, $6 in LA. Electricity and water, also high. Problems abound, but can we not say they’re crazy out there? That makes us unkind and shallow. Let’s disagree, civilly. It’s not as if we are moving there after all…Who wants to pay for grocery bags?
